Dissolving illusions book

Breathing function is so impaired that a mechanical apparatus is required to force air in and out of the patient’s lungs. Seven iron lungs were shipped to Hickory, two of them from Boston. John Bryan, 8, uses oxygen inhalator. It feeds oxygen to nose of patient who has difficulty in breathing normally.

Dissolving illusions book. Dissolving Illusions devotes entire chapters to the complex and fascinating histories of vaccination for polio, measles and whooping cough. On polio: “As of today, no programs have been funded to investigate or validate the scientific findings that implicate associations between chemicals like DDT and arsenic and the syndrome of poliomyelitis.”

Mar 14, 2014 · Dissolving Illusions:Disease, Vaccines, and The Forgotten History by Suzanne Humphries MD. A Book Review by Jeffrey Dach MD. Polio vaccination workers in Pakistan are a favorite target of militants who have been killing them off for years now. Perhaps these AK-47 wielding gunmen have read Dr. Humphries’ excellent book on vaccine illusions ...

including Suzanne Humphries and Roman Bystrianyk in their book “Dissolving Illusions”, have attempted. Even more egregious is the attempt to take a monumentally significant public health issue like polio and, using “alternative facts”, minimize its significance. In Humphries’ and Bystrianyk’s book, the subject of this article, they evenDissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and The Forgotten History: https://amzn.to/3jdYJFz (affiliate link) Review about book that talks about vaccines.*Vis...See the seller’s listing for full details and description of any imperfections. ISBN. 9781480216891. Book Title. Dissolving Illusions : Disease, Vaccines, and the Forgotten History. Item Length. 9in. Publisher. CreateSpace.Dissolving Illusions is meticulously researched and footnoted. Reading it is an undertaking--the book is 479 pages long--but it's worth it. Dr. Suzanne Humphries, M.D., and her co-author Roman Bystrianyk, present the other side of the story: the forgotten history the role of poor hygiene, crowding, malnutrition, and harmful medical practices …“Dissolving Illusions” is one of my favorite books on vaccines, so I was honored to write the foreword for this 10th anniversary edition. The ‘Safe and Effective’ Narrative Is a Carefully Fabricated Illusion. That word, “illusions,” is an apt one, because the vaccine industry really is all about promoting illusions.Nov 10, 2018 · This is a longer version of my post on Friday, November 9th, 2018. It is a lengthy discussion of why Suzanne Humphries, MD and Roman Bystrianyk’s book Dissolving Illusions misrepresents the dangers of polio, one in a series of posts that should comprehensively show the problems with their claims. It covers far more than just polio, but is ...

But is this really true?Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from ...The single biggest problem in communication is the illusion that it has taken place. — George Bernard Shaw S The single biggest problem in communication is the illusion that it has...Immerse yourself into the fascinating world of illusions and let our captivating rooms play tricks on your mind! Get a glimpse of infinity, take a walk in the upside-down world, and …Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering information, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from infectious diseases.These street art murals will blow your mind, including a terrifying crevasse in Ireland and giant fake bookshelf in the Netherlands. Increasingly, it seems that today’s most widely...Breathing function is so impaired that a mechanical apparatus is required to force air in and out of the patient’s lungs. Seven iron lungs were shipped to Hickory, two of them from Boston. John Bryan, 8, uses oxygen inhalator. It feeds oxygen to nose of patient who has difficulty in breathing normally.Mar 14, 2014 · Dissolving Illusions:Disease, Vaccines, and The Forgotten History by Suzanne Humphries MD. A Book Review by Jeffrey Dach MD. Polio vaccination workers in Pakistan are a favorite target of militants who have been killing them off for years now. Perhaps these AK-47 wielding gunmen have read Dr. Humphries’ excellent book on vaccine illusions ...

Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering information, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other …But is this really true?Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from ...Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and the Forgotten History is the fruit of many years of research by Humphries and researcher Roman Bystrianyk. The book relies on facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources to paint a realistic picture of conditions in the 19 th century.But is this really true?Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from ...Target Audience. The book “Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines and the Forgotten History” by Suzanne Humphries is primarily targeted at a diverse audience interested in public health, medical history, and critical thinking.It is recommended reading for the following groups: Healthcare Professionals The book presents a critical analysis …But is this really true?Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from ...

Seagull sound.

But is this really true?Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from ...Oct 30, 2023 · Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering information, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from infectious diseases. For 225 years, doctors have been saying that, and for 225 years, those doctors have been ignored. That’s one of the reasons we wrote the second book, ‘The Dissolving Illusions Companion book.’. “It’s another huge book, about 600 pages, with 230-something doctors giving different quotes about what they saw, boots on the …You can reverse or amend your irrevocable trust and its terms and deal with your current financial situation without breaking the law if your circumstances change. The laws for doi...

"I hate the four walls, the cages / They told me dissolve the patience / We livin' through all the changes," he raps on "collage"; "All these tribulations, hope it make …But is this really true?Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from ...“Dissolving Illusions” is one of my favorite books on vaccines, so I was honored to write the foreword for this 10th anniversary edition. The vaccine industry intentionally deceives us about the risks and benefits of vaccines in order to make a profit, with complete disregard for human suffering and the destruction of public health over time.“Dissolving Illusions” is one of my favorite books on vaccines, so I was honored to write the foreword for this 10th anniversary edition. The ‘Safe and Effective’ Narrative Is a Carefully Fabricated Illusion. That word, “illusions,” is an apt one, because the vaccine industry really is all about promoting illusions.Mar 26, 2024 · Fully referenced, this book is a comprehensive resource that provokes critical thinking on the real history of medicine and vaccination. A must-read for anyone thirsty for historical controversial realities that bridge current false medical dogmas to a still-tangible past. Suzanne Humphries, MD has updated her book "Dissolving Illusions" and Mercola.com has written about it today. Here is just one section of the article. Read the rest. The 2013 book "Dissolving Illusions" is a classic on vaccines and infectious diseases. This 600 page update should be extremely interesting.So, we’ve added another 200 pages to our original book, ‘Dissolving Illusions,’ based on what we’ve discovered since. So, people who’ve already bought the book won’t be disappointed because there’ll be some new things included, and people who have never read it will get a bigger, deeper picture of the history.”You can reverse or amend your irrevocable trust and its terms and deal with your current financial situation without breaking the law if your circumstances change. The laws for doi...Books. Add to Wishlist. Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and the Forgotten History 10th Anniversary Edition Companion and Reference. by Suzanne Humphries, Roman Bystrianyk. Paperback. $29.00. Learn more. SHIP THIS ITEM. Temporarily Out of Stock Online. PICK UP IN STORE. Check Availability at Nearby Stores. Overview.“Dissolving Illusions” is a book written by Suzanne Humphries that explores the myths and misconceptions surrounding vaccines and provides a critical analysis of vaccine history. It offers a ...Jul 27, 2013 · Malattie, vaccini e la storia dimenticata: dissolving illusion (Fuori collana) (Italian Edition) Italian Edition | by Suzanne Humphries and MD Roman Bystrianyk | May 1, 2018 4.7 out of 5 stars

Nov 16, 2022 ... Dissolving Illusions by Suzanne Humphries. 0 1. amother Daylily. Post Thu, Nov 17 2022, 12:44 pm. Dr sears the vaccine book. Dr Paul the vaccine ...

But is this really true?Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from ... Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from infectious diseases.Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering information, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from infectious diseases.Dissolving Illusions is a book by Suzanne Humphries and Roman Bystrianyk that challenges the myths and facts about vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical …Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering information, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from infectious diseases. In this interview, Dr. Suzanne Humphries discusses the recent update to her classic book, “Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and the Forgotten History,” published in 2013. “Dissolving Illusions” is one of my favorite books on vaccines, so I was honored to write the foreword for this 10th anniversary edition. The ‘Safe and Effective’ Narrative Is a […] Mar 19, 2024 · Dr. Suzanne Humphries deserves an award for bringing the load of vaccine record and history to a finely orchestrated; and lengthy, book. The parent of 4 children, I had never questioned vaccines before 2 of our children had a severe reaction to their shots at a joint appointment in which my daughter received her Kindergarten shots and our son (then not yet 3) received the shots required ... Download PDF - Dissolving Illusions. Disease, Vaccines And The Forgotten History [EPUB] [1ah5aem1s1d0]. Not too long ago, ... If you are author or own the copyright of this book, please report to us by using this DMCA report form. Report DMCA. CONTACT. 1243 Schamberger Freeway Apt. 502Port Orvilleville, ON H8J-6M9Kupte knihu Dissolving Illusions (Suzanne Humphries MD, Roman Bystrianyk) za 674 Kč v ověřeném obchodě. Prolistujte stránky knihy, ... Avatar, the Last Airbender: The Kyoshi Novels (Box Set) 676 Kč Koupit. The 48 Laws of Power 602 Kč Koupit. House of Leaves 405 Kč Koupit. Twisted Lies 214 Kč Koupit. Dune Messiah 277 KčMar 19, 2024 · Dr. Suzanne Humphries deserves an award for bringing the load of vaccine record and history to a finely orchestrated; and lengthy, book. The parent of 4 children, I had never questioned vaccines before 2 of our children had a severe reaction to their shots at a joint appointment in which my daughter received her Kindergarten shots and our son (then not yet 3) received the shots required ...

Lock screen settings.

I need a free ride to work no money.

Dissolving Illusions : Disease, Vaccines, and the Forgotten History by Humphries, Suzanne; Bystrianyk, ... Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from infectious diseases.Dissolving Illusions devotes entire chapters to the complex and fascinating histories of vaccination for polio, measles and whooping cough. On polio: “As of today, no programs have been funded to investigate or validate the scientific findings that implicate associations between chemicals like DDT and arsenic and the syndrome of poliomyelitis.”Dive into the extended Dissolving Illusions: 10th Anniversary Edition, where you’ll explore an additional 200+ pages, over 350 new references, and even more charts that challenge traditional medical dogma. $34.00. Quantity.The single biggest problem in communication is the illusion that it has taken place. — George Bernard Shaw S The single biggest problem in communication is the illusion that it has...Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and The Forgotten History by Humphries MD, Suzanne; Bystrianyk, Roman - ISBN 10: 1480216895 - ISBN 13: 9781480216891 - CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform - 2013 - Softcover ... Book Description Paperback. Condition: new.Substances that have ionic molecules or polar molecules generally dissolve in water because water molecules have the ability to surround the those molecules completely and disperse...Feb 25, 2024 · “Dissolving Illusions” is one of my favorite books on vaccines, so I was honored to write the foreword for this 10th anniversary edition. The ‘Safe and Effective’ Narrative Is a Carefully Fabricated Illusion. That word, “illusions,” is an apt one, because the vaccine industry really is all about promoting illusions. Dissolving Illusions Kindle Edition. by Suzanne Humphries (Author), Roman Bystrianyk (Author)Format: Kindle Edition. 4.9 2,879 ratings. See all formats and editions. Not too long ago, lethal infections were feared in the Western world.Amazon.in - Buy Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and the Forgotten History 10th Anniversary Edition book online at best prices in India on Amazon.in. Read Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and the Forgotten History 10th Anniversary Edition book reviews & author details and more at Amazon.in. Free delivery on qualified orders.Guillermo Lasso, accused of embezzlement, is one of the only right-wing leaders in South America The president of Ecuador, Guillermo Lasso, dissolved the country’s National Assembl...Vitamin B6 is a water-soluble vitamin. Water-soluble vitamins dissolve in water so the body cannot store them. Leftover amounts of the vitamin leave the body through the urine. Alt... ….

Dissolving Illusions DOWNLOAD eBooks . Download Dissolving Illusions PDF/ePub or read online books in Mobi eBooks. Click Download or Read Online button to get Dissolving Illusions book now. This website allows unlimited access to, at the time of writing, more than 1.5 million titles, including hundreds of thousands of titles in various …Mar 26, 2024 · Dissolving Illusions meticulously presents facts and figures from forgotten medical journals, books, newspapers, and diverse sources: dispelling the prevailing false narratives that largely attribute increased lifespan and premature death prevention to medical interventions. Are you prepared to dissolve some of your own illusions and engage in ... Dissolving Illusions devotes entire chapters to the complex and fascinating histories of vaccination for polio, measles and whooping cough. On polio: “As of today, no programs have been funded to investigate or validate the scientific findings that implicate associations between chemicals like DDT and arsenic and the syndrome of poliomyelitis.”“Dissolving Illusions” is a seminal book that critically examines vaccine science and history. The new edition includes 200 additional pages, offering updated insights and deepening the historical context of vaccine development and its societal impactsDissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from infectious diseases.Dr. Suzanne Humphries deserves an award for bringing the load of vaccine record and history to a finely orchestrated; and lengthy, book. The parent of 4 children, I had never questioned vaccines before 2 of our children had a severe reaction to their shots at a joint appointment in which my daughter received her Kindergarten shots and our son (then …Optical illusions have been found in cave paintings, so an optical illusion is not considered an invention but instead is the result of man imitating the geometric forms seen in na...Feb 24th, 2024Robert HumphriesRobert Humphries Service Manager Bowdon, GA 30108 [email protected] 678-409-6918 Looking For Company To Grow With And Us Jan 8th, 2024. Learning American Sign Language Tom HumphriesLearning American Sign Language DVD-Tom Humphries 2004-12 72 Dialogues Are Presented To Demonstrate … Dissolving illusions book, Dissolving Illusions meticulously presents facts and figures from forgotten medical journals, books, newspapers, and diverse sources: dispelling the prevailing false narratives that largely attribute increased lifespan and premature death prevention to medical interventions. Are you prepared to dissolve some of your own illusions and engage in ..., Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and The Forgotten History at Amazon.com. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. Skip to main ... 5.0 out of 5 stars Great book, very informative, a must read for straightforward, unbiased info. Reviewed in Canada on April 2, 2019., Dissolving Illusions. Paperback – 27 July 2013. by Suzanne Humphries (Author), Roman Bystrianyk (Author) 2,640. See all formats and editions. EMI starts at ₹104. No Cost EMI available EMI options. Save Extra with 3 offers. Bank Offer (2): 10% Instant Discount up to INR 500 on J and K Bank Card Non-EMI Trxn., An eye-opening book that anyone interested in vaccines and the history of infectious diseases should read. Dissolving Illusions is meticulously researched and footnoted. . Reading it is an undertaking--the book is 479 pages long--but it's worth it. Dr. Suzanne Humphries, M.D., and her co-author Roman Bystrianyk, present the other side of the story: the forgotten history the role of poor ..., Depth of Field - Depth of field is an optical technique that is used to reinforce the illusion of depth. Learn about depth of field and the anti-aliasing technique. Advertisement A..., But is this really true?Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from infectious diseases., Prices (including delivery) for Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and The Forgotten History by Roman Bystrianyk, Humphries Md, Suzanne range from $42.33 at Amazon.com.au Prime . ... Book published July 2013 by CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform. Add an alert. Add to a list EAN: 8601200606058: Publisher: ..., Coming up on four years of scamdemic Harmacide, officially, 3-11-24 makes four. I tried to tell a friend the agenda was still present and palpable., Unveil the concealed realities that shaped the Western world's health evolution, transitioning from an era overshadowed by the specter of infectious diseases to an epoch of prosperity, relative health, and well-being. Dive into the extended Dissolving Illusions: 10th Anniversary Edition, where you'll explore an additional 200+ pages, over 300 new references, and even more charts that challenge ..., Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from infectious diseases., So much for quieting your inner narcissist. According to Buddhist teaching, the self is an illusion. The religion preaches a fundamentally selfless worldview, encouraging followers..., Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from infectious diseases., Dissolving Illusions meticulously presents facts and figures from forgotten medical journals, books, newspapers, and diverse sources: dispelling the prevailing …, Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and ..., But is this really true?Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from ..., Dissolving Illusions meticulously presents facts and figures from forgotten medical journals, books, newspapers, and diverse sources: dispelling the prevailing false narratives that largely attribute increased lifespan and premature death prevention to medical interventions. Are you prepared to dissolve some of your own illusions and engage in ..., Sep 10, 2023 ... ... book Dissolving Illusions. If you want to understand the present, you have to understand the past. The following reading list contains many ..., Dissolving Illusions meticulously presents facts and figures from forgotten medical journals, books, newspapers, and diverse sources: dispelling the prevailing false narratives that largely attribute increased lifespan and premature death prevention to medical interventions. Are you prepared to dissolve some of your own illusions and engage in ..., Ursodiol: learn about side effects, dosage, special precautions, and more on MedlinePlus Ursodiol is used to dissolve gallstones in people who do not want surgery or cannot have su..., STORY AT-A-GLANCE. In this interview, Dr. Suzanne Humphries discusses the release of the 10th anniversary edition of “Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and the Forgotten History,” one of my favorite books on vaccines, originally published in 2013. I was honored to write the foreword for the update of this classic., But is this really true?Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering graphs, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from infectious diseases., Oct 30, 2023 · Dissolving Illusions details facts and figures from long-overlooked medical journals, books, newspapers, and other sources. Using myth-shattering information, this book shows that vaccines, antibiotics, and other medical interventions are not responsible for the increase in lifespan and the decline in mortality from infectious diseases. , Story at-a-glance. The updated and expanded 10th anniversary edition of “Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and the Forgotten History,” by Dr. Suzanne Humphries and Roman Bystrianyk, empowers readers with information, encourages critical examination of vaccine policies and advocates for informed consent in medical decisions., 6 likes. Like. “Perhaps the best prevention and treatment that exists against all toxin-mediated diseases will never be accepted by conventional medicine, simply because it cannot be patented.”. ― Suzanne Humphries, Dissolving Illusions. 2 likes. Like. “Belief and fear are powerful influences to the psyche., Wrong About Polio: A Review of Suzanne Humphries, MD and Roman Bystrianyk’s “Dissolving Illusions” Part 1 (the short version) Suzanne Humphries and Roman Bystrianyk's book Dissolving Illusions make numerous egregious errors or deceptive statements about polio. Here is part 1 in a series about the truth and true …, Not too long ago, lethal infections were feared in the Western world. Since that time, many countries have undergone a transformation from disease cesspools to much safer, healthier habitats. Starting in the mid-1800s, there was a steady drop in deaths from all infectious diseases, decreasing to relatively minor levels by the early 1900s. The history of that transformation involves famine ..., Dr. Suzanne Humphries deserves an award for bringing the load of vaccine record and history to a finely orchestrated; and lengthy, book. The parent of 4 children, I had never questioned vaccines before 2 of our children had a severe reaction to their shots at a joint appointment in which my daughter received her Kindergarten shots and our son (then not yet 3) received the shots required ..., Buy Dissolving Illusions: Disease, Vaccines, and the Forgotten History 10th Anniversary Edition by Bystrianyk, Roman, Humphries, Dr. Suzanne (ISBN: 9798986936314) from Amazon's Book Store. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders., ... book. Sample Book Insights: #1 The. ... Summary of Suzanne Humphries & Roman Bystrianyk's Dissolving Illusions ... Please note: This is a companion version & not&nb..., Dissolving Illusions. Paperback – 27 July 2013. by Suzanne Humphries (Author), Roman Bystrianyk (Author) 2,640. See all formats and editions. EMI starts at ₹104. No Cost EMI available EMI options. Save Extra with 3 offers. Bank Offer (2): 10% Instant Discount up to INR 500 on J and K Bank Card Non-EMI Trxn., In the New York Times' recent article on the mystery of why laptops require special scanning procedures on planes (they're mostly scanned to give us the illusion of security, descr..., Unveil the concealed realities that shaped the Western world's health evolution, transitioning from an era overshadowed by the specter of infectious diseases to an epoch of prosperity, relative health, and well-being. Dive into the extended Dissolving Illusions: 10th Anniversary Edition, where you'll explore an additional 200+ pages, over 300 new references, and even more charts that challenge ...,